Urban Economics and Planning

Urban Economics and Planning

Components of Environmental Quality and its Impact on Social Deviations in Squatter Areas (Case Study: Maragheh City)

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
Ali Azar 1
Parina Sohrabderakhshi 2
1 Associate Professor, Department of Architecture and Urban Planning, Maragheh Branch, Islamic Azad University, Maragheh, Iran
2 Ph.D. Candidate, Department of Architecture and Urban Planning, Tabriz branch, Islamic Azad University, Tabriz, Iran
10.22034/uep.2024.428971.1441
Abstract
Introduction 
During the last few decades, some issues, including industrial, economic, and social developments, village-to-city migration, and the growth and expansion of marginal areas, have resulted in deviations and social damages. Informal settlements in Iran, like many developing countries, manifest the growing trend of spatial inequalities and increasing poverty in cities. The feeling of security, as one of the essential needs of human beings, plays a significant role in the development of a sense of belonging to a place and the vitality of the citizens so the presence of security is one of the important variables in strengthening the human city and the identity of the cities. Today, social problems are considered as the most important threatening factors in the cities. Marginalization is considered one of the important centers for the occurrence of social problems. Due to the expansion of marginalization, the social-economic insecurity increases. Social deviations and criminality have become the symbol of marginal areas and facilitate the occurrence of crime in these areas. Overcrowding and excessive density in marginal areas, on the one hand, and the inferior culture of marginal residents, on the other hand, increase the potential of crime occurrence in the marginal neighborhoods of metropolitan areas. Lack of cultural training, low education of the citizens, their resistance to innovation, and mixing with the superior culture of the mother city have led to the historical lag of these regions. Therefore, despite several decades of appearance of marginalization and the change of several generations, the dominant culture of marginalization still prevails in these neighborhoods. The creativity and innovation of this research are to examine the relationship between social deviations and environmental quality and to determine the impact of environmental design components in reducing the crime rate in marginal areas. The current research aims to investigate the components of environmental quality and its impact on reducing social deviations in marginal areas in Maragheh City.
Materials and Methods
The research is conducted by a descriptive-analytical method and it is practical research. Library methods and field observations (questionnaires) have been used to collect the data. The statistical population includes all the marginal residents of Maragheh City. Using the stratified probability sampling method and the Kochran formula, 320 people were chosen as the sample of the study. Eighteen variables were used to evaluate the role of environmental quality in social deviations. The studied area in this research is the marginal areas of Maragheh city, including Anzab, Mikael-Abad, Zeinal-Abad, and Pahrabad. In the analysis of the data, SPSS software, chi-squared test (x2) as well as Simple Linear Regression test were used. In univariate regression, the changes of an independent variable on the dependent variable were evaluated. Considering that, there is an independent variable (environmental quality) and a dependent variable (social deviations) in this research, the univariate (simple) regression test was used. To determine the factors of the environmental quality scale and summarize the main factors of crime occurrence, the exploratory factor analysis model was used.
Findings
The analysis of the field study shows that the environmental quality in the marginal areas of Maragheh city suffers from some problems and it is largely lower than the average level. To test the impact of environmental quality on social deviations in marginal areas, an univariate regression test was used (Sig= 0.000; Beta= 0.32). it means that each unit of increase in the unfavorable state of environmental quality leads to a 0.32 increase in social deviations. The results of the univariate regression test indicate that with each unit increase in the unfavorable condition of environmental quality, social deviations increase by 32%. According to the results of exploratory factor analysis of the environmental quality variable, 3 factors were extracted after Varimax rotation. In this study, the impact of environmental quality on social deviations in marginalized areas was confirmed. However, no significant relationship was found between age and social deviations in marginalized areas, and also there was not any significant difference between social deviations in marginalized areas based on the gender of the subjects. Therefore, it can be concluded that the quality of the environment has a relatively equal effect on the social deviations of the residents, while gender or age cannot be considered as factors affecting the social deviations of the residents of the marginal areas and it is necessary to improve the environmental quality of the marginal areas and increase the required facilities as well as reduce the harmful factors.
Conclusion
According to the results of the factor analysis, three factors, including the functional-service factor, density and the space presence factor, and physical–user factor reduce the crime occurrence in the marginal areas. The results of the univariate regression test indicate that with each unit increase in the unfavorable condition of environmental quality, social deviations increase by 32%. In the marginal areas of Maragheh City, unemployment, violence, and the commission of various crimes, including murder, poverty, and addiction, show a high rate. The results of the research show that with urban planning and design, including the development of public spaces, renovation of houses, widening the passages, giving services, good night lighting, the establishment of some state offices in these areas, desirable public transportation and adaptation of urban furniture will encourage the residents to go to the public spaces and help to ensure the security of these areas.
Keywords
Crime
Environmental Quality
Maragheh
Social Deviations
Squatter Areas

Subjects

[1] Abbas Zadegan, M., Creating a sense of citizenship according to social psychological needs in new cities, collection of essays on the identity of new cities, Tehran, 2004. [ In Persian].
[2] Ahmadi Marand, N., Balilan Asl, L, an important study of vitality in the quality of urban spaces and its factors, International Conference on Man, Architecture, Civil Engineering and the City, Tabriz,2014; [ In Persian].
[3] Azar, A., Azarmi M., Abdulzadeh Taraf, A., investigation of the role of environmental planning and design in the level of urban security in marginal areas of Tabriz city, Geography and Environmental Planning Journal,2018, No. 32, : 54-41. [ In Persian].
[4] Azar, A., Mohammadi Birang, M., investigation and analysis of women’s sense of security in public spaces with an emphasis on urban parks: the study of Tabriz, Journal of Urban Ecology Research,2018, 2, :‌27-40. doi: 10.30473/grup.2020.7076. [ In Persian].
[5] Başak, A. M.; Deniz, A. M. & Ertan, A. M., (2017). “The Romanization of poverty: Spatial stigmatization of Roma neighborhoods in Turkey”. Romani Studies,2017, 27: 73 – 93.
[6] Bashariyah, Tehmurt., Mozafari, M. S, The relationship between marginalization and crime in Kermanshah (case study: Dolatabad marginal area of Kermanshah in 2013, Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology Research, 2017, (6) 11; 161-19. [ In Persian].
[7] Batisani, N. and Yarnal, B. (2008)., Urban expansion in Centre County, Pennsylvania: Spatial dynamics and Landscape transformations, Applied Geography, 2008, doi: 10.1016/j.apgeog.2008.08.007.
[8] Clowrad, R., Ohlin, L., Criminal Behavior Systems, New York: Holt ,Rinehart and Winston Inc,1960.
Cozens, P.‌, “Sustainable urban development and crime prevention through nvironmental design for the British city. Towards an effective urban environmentalism for the 21st century.” Cities, 2002,19(2): 129-137.
[9] Fattah, K. N.,Walters, P., A Good Place for the Poor!”. Counternarratives to Territorial Stigmatisation from Two Informal Settlements in Dhaka. Social Inclusion,2020, 8: 55-65. 10.17645/si.v8i1.2318.
[10] Garnier, S., Predicting Dynamical Crime Distribution from Environmental and Social Influences, Frontiers in Applied Mathematics and Statistics,2018,‌4‌:‌1- 10, https://doi.org/10.3389/fams.2018.00013.
[11] Hataminejad, H., Eshghi Chaharborj, A., Optimum location of physical development of Maragheh city with emphasis on urban sustainability, Journal of Geographical Survey of Space,2015, 6(‌19‎);15-31‌. [ In Persian].
[12] Hezajaribi, J., Amin Saremi, N., Yusofundi, F., the effect of marginalization on the occurrence of social crimes in Kermanshah city in 2010, Journal of Police Management Research,2008, 4(1), 73-86. [In Persian].
[13] Karam ollah, J., Yusufund, P., social capital and sense of security among peripheral and central areas (Khorramabad city), Research Journal of Order and Security, 2023, 2(‌14): 57-82 doi:10.22034/OSRA.2021.95471. [ In Persian].
[14] Kargar, B., Urban security, Tehran, publications of the Geographical Organization of the Armed Forces, 2007‌. [ In Persian].
[15] Kidd, S. A., Youth Homelessness and Social Stigma. J. Youth Adolescence,2007, 36: 291–299.
[16] Milliken, J., urban safety and security: Lessons from the last two decades and emergent issues, Synthesis report of the conference reviewing the State of Safety in World Cities: Safer Cities +20, 2016, Geneva 6-8 July.
[17] Mohammadi, M.,Akbari, H., Fouladiyan, M., Perception of text city residents of marginal residents; The coping strategies of residents of privileged areas of Mashhad city with marginalization, Contemporary Sociological Researches (Scientific-Research), 2023, 12(22): 205-238 ,doi:10.22084/csr.2023.27271.2185 [ In Persian].
[18] Najafi Kani, A.A., Hamidi, Kh., An analysis of bottlenecks and physical development strategies of informal settlements. Case example: Marginal and Peripheral Neighborhoods of Babylon, Space Geographic Survey Journal, 2023, 11(39): 217-238, doi: 10.30488/gps.2020.219392.3187. [ In Persian].
[19] Nazarian, A., Tavallaei.,S, Determining the direction of physical development of Andimeshk city using data and geographic information system. The Quarterly Journal of Geographical Satellite RS of the Land, third year, 2007, 1(9): 1-9. [ In Persian].
[20] Ogas Mendez, A. F. & Isoda, Y., Examining the Effect of Squatter Settlements in the Evolution of Spatial Fragmentation in the Housing Market of the City of Buenos Aires by Using Geographical Weighted Regression”.ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information,2021, 10(6): 359. 10.3390/ijgi10060359.
[21] Pakzad, J., Bozur, H., The Alphabet of Environmental Psychology for Designers, Tehran, Armanshahr Publications, 2014. [ In Persian].
[22] Rabbani, R. Urban Sociology, Tehran, Samt Publications,2008. [ In Persian].
[23] Report on the status of unsettled urban areas and the performance of provincial and city headquarters , Secretariat of the headquarters of sustainable regeneration of target areas and localities of East Azerbaijan province, General Directorate of Roads and Urban Development of East Azerbaijan province. 2014. [ In Persian].
[24] Salcedo‌, Rodrigo. (2023). The Last Slum: Moving from Illegal Settlements to Subsidized Home Ownership in Chile, Urban Affairs Review, 2023, 46(1) 1, 10.1177/1078087410368487.
[25] Sarokhani, B., Hashemnejad., Investigating the relationship between social capital (its components) and the feeling of social security among the youth of Sari. Sociology of Youth Studies,2012: 2-81. [ In Persian].
[26] The results of the general population and housing census, Iran Statistical Center,2015.
[27] Tosin, B., Squatter settlements’ impact on perception of security in mass housing schemes in developing African cities : The case of Abuja, Nigeria, journal of Urban Regeneration & Renewal, 2022, 16 (‌2): 50-65.
[28] Wacquant, L., Territorial Stigmatization in the Age of Advanced Marginality”. Thesis Eleven,2007, 91(1): 66–77.
[29] Yirmibesoglu, F., Ergun ,N.,.Property and Personal Crime in Istanbul, European Planning Studies,2007, 15(3): 339-355.
Urban Economics and Planning
Volume 4, Issue 4
Autumn 2024
Pages 148-162

  • Receive Date 08 December 2023
  • Revise Date 27 January 2024
  • Accept Date 12 February 2024